Well in case you haven't heard yet
Scotland is having a referendum on independence exactly one year from
today. Currently the polls are pretty much tied with only a few
percent difference. Though it's becoming clear the yes vote is slowly
creeping up the charts, without to much surprise for those committed
to the independence cause.
For the past ten years I've been living
in Cornwall (I now live in South Africa). I say Cornwall
deliberately here. For many Cornwall is not England and considers
itself a completely separate nation, with it's own culture,
language and of course the pasty. However the chances of Cornwall
getting it's own assembly, never mind independence in the next 50
years are probably similar to the odds for winning the lottery. The
Cornish language was only recently officially recognised by the British government despite growing
numbers of speakers and it's unique Cornish dialect of English is
often overlooked as a valid form of cultural expression, simply being
lumped in with all things West Country. Not only this, Cornwall may
well be run in the most undemocratic way possible with the outcome of
local voters consultations being overturned by local councillors and
MP's more than once. Why is any of this relevant to Scotland and it's
quest for independence? Because prior to the creation of the new
Scottish Parliament in 1998 Scotland faced much of the same issues as
Cornwall does now. Not least being short changed by the UK out of
it's income. In 2014 we the Scottish people have an obligation to ourselves to demand
more and protect our little piece of paradise.
While living in Cornwall the Scotland
debate came up frequently. Before the election of the SNP
parliamentary expression of Scotland's socialist leaning was treated
with bitterness and scorn. “Why should the Scots be entitled to
free university education and I'm not when England is paying for it.”
For most Scot's who haven't lived in England it's hard to imagine the
levels of ignorance the majority have English people have regarding
both Scottish economics and culture. Frequently as a Scot I have been
asked to speak properly or in fact told you must be very grateful to
be here. Can you imagine? Though I would not say that this is the
norm my identity is certainly greeted with a degree of
ridicule that wouldn't be extended to other nationalities. The
Cornish who can be categorised as culturally distinct have a
completely different approach. It's clear to decipher the line that
separates Scots from the English, though we might not be able to
specify exactly what it is. With the Cornish that line becomes almost
invisible, though it's there and the Scots and the Cornish stand on
the same side.
Since the election of the Scottish National Party in
Scotland the Scotland debate has for good reason increased in
enormity. I remember being informed of the first SNP win quite clearly,
to say that people were surprised south of the border was a bit of an
understatement. That surprise within the English populous lead to the
belief that Scotland had gone right wing and had become to their
dismay entirely anti-english, which was not the case. It's a strange
set of affairs when you have to explain that the SNP find them selves
in the unusual position of being more left wing than Labour. In the
lead up to the Scottish election in 2007 the Scots had now begun to
understand that the Scottish Labour Party was nothing more than a
mouth piece for Westminster policy, which was not what the Scottish
people wanted. The Scottish people wanted a more autonomous national
platform that protected their interests which the SNP offered. Not
only this due to proportional representation Scotland had a far more
fluid way of expressing these views at the ballot box, instead of
being stuck with the Westminster first past the post system that
primarily leaves Westminster politics in a two horse race. In 2011
once the SNP won majority leadership in Scotland the questions and
accusations started flooding in and from complete strangers too
uninvited in coffee shops and everything. They simply didn't
understand the Scottish agenda and the mainstream media didn't help
much. “Do you think Scotland will vote for independence?” “If
it wants to, yes.” “You'll never survive on your own.” “New
Zealand seems to be doing rather well and it's only got a population
of 4 million.” “You're too poor.” “How can a nation be poor
when it controls world whisky supply? Oh and we have oil.” It's
nice to be able to have conversations that totally alter another
persons perspectives. And it's not their fault they don't know, it's
to do with propaganda. The Yes Campaign have 365 days to unravel 400
years of propaganda.
For most English people it would be
hard for them to understand that Scottish independence finds itself
up for discussion in Scottish playgrounds but it does. I have no idea
how it got there especially predating the release of Braveheart. I think the stealing of the Stone of
Destiny has something to do with it. I mean it's a pretty romantic
idea that a stolen ancient stone that belongs to Scotland sits in a
foreign country under a another monarchs throne. Education also plays
a huge role in this, it wasn't until quite late on that I discovered
that the Queen was not the Queen of England but in fact the Queen of
the United Kingdom via mutual agreement. That is what we are up
against on both sides. It's quite fantastical that one of England's
most famous monarch died unmarried and childless and yet few follow
the dots to put two and two together.
I have to be honest few in my social
circle are voting no. Which leaves me with little understanding of
the intricacies of the no campaign. Though I do disagree with the
brandishing of the No Campaign as 'Project Fear'. I don't think
people involved in the Yes Campaign understand that those voting for
the status quo to remain in the UK are scared. The reason they are
scared much like other segments of the UK is that they have been
exposed to imperialist propaganda all their lives and find it easier
to believe the lies and to dismiss the truth. The imperial centre
London is not the be all and end all of what is going on in the UK. In
England in particular it is obvious that just about all systems are
running on the brink of collapse from transport to health services. I
think the best remedy for anybody intending to vote no is to put them
in the waiting room of an English NHS hospital and then take them to
the worst Scottish hospital and see if they can notice the
difference. Maybe it's time to start taking the Scots on tours south
of the border to expand there cultural knowledge of the UK and we
won't be going to London. Take your eyes of the spectacle of
Westminster, the monarchy and celebrity life. Adventures into lesser
known England might change a few minds completely about the state of
the Union, no psychiatric beds, no social housing, whole families
living in B & B's; that will make you sit up and pay attention.
For some strange reason when I think
about those considering voting no an image creeps into my mind. I see
a family picnic on the shores of a loch on the day of independence
and a giant mushroom cloud appearing above the mountains on the other
side of the loch. Why do I think of this? Well because life without
nuclear weapons would clearly mean that the rest of the world would
want to bomb us. Does that include the remaining part of the UK? The
strange thing is that people really think that we would be
threatened. I find it hard to believe that the cold war mentality of
nuclear wipe out is still alive and well. Avoiding nuclear wipe out
is exactly why you would want to get rid of nuclear deterrents. My
only fear is that the UK will forget to inform the appropriate
parties when the time comes. “Oh yeah we don't control that bit any
more” and we take the flak anyway. Despite this minor problem I
believe that Scotland as a small nation will be able to get on with
things quite nicely.
Other things that have cropped up for
me in conversation about independence is the prospect of war, border
control, passports, the role of the SNP post independence and the
lack of experience of Scottish politicians on an international arena.
These revelations crack me up as I wonder what the main role of the
British Empire has been over the last century. Mainly giving back
what was not ours in the first place. Is it not fitting that this
should end in returning the sovereignty of the four nations and well
cutting the Cornish some slack. Most nations recognise that there is
little to gain from preventing states from becoming independent, as
neo-colonialism turns quite a good profit these days. Not that I
think that would be the case with an independent Scotland, though I wouldn't put it past them. More than
this through the procedure of retuning sovereignty the UK has become
pretty good at handling the passport issue. For some highly bizarre
reason people seem to think that all Scottish people will have their
passports revoked on September the 19th 2014 unless they swear allegiance to the UK. This completely overlooks long standing
arrangements that the UK has with other nations such as Ireland, that
address border control also. Never mind that we issue passports to
places like the Isle of Man, the Channel Islands and some residents
of Hong Kong. So unless the UK decide to throw an unsightly hissy fit,
I doubt passport and border control will be much of an issue. A vote
for independence is not a vote for the SNP, should we vote yes in the
independence referendum we then get to build a new parliament in
2016. In the new parliament one has to assume that many things will
change due to the increased responsibilities of the Scottish nation. In addition many Scottish Westminster politicians who wish to
continue their political careers will have to take a place in the
newly formed Scottish government. The list of politicians might
include Gordon Brown, Alastair Darling, Menzies Campbell and Charles
Kennedy providing Scotland with experienced international
politicians.
Why am I so interested in all this I've
live outside of Scotland for ten years and now live in South Africa?
Well it's where I'm from and one day where I hope to return to. Hey
and at least somebody is paying attention with one year to go. It's not like the
potential break up of the UK in one years time is making the UK
headlines as it should. Where is Scotland's official countdown timer
aren't we a little more significant than the Olympics?
No comments:
Post a Comment